FARMERS toil under the scorching heat of the sun almost all day. Yet they can barely survive and make ends meet.
Rico Dagli has been a farmer for more than 20 years now. He’s been depending on carabaos to till his land. All this hard work would bring home P6,000 to his family each month.
Hundreds of farmers in Negros Oriental, like Dagli, have long been waiting for help from the government. And just this year, farm tractors from the Department of Agrarian Reform finally arrived.
Not their kind of tractor
Some are happy about the tractor deal.
“Malaking tulong sa amin yung traktora na naibigay sa amin,” says Freddie Salgon, chairman of Hacienda Carmen. “Sa katotohanan, yung sugar cane na ngayon tinatanim namin naging productive.”
But others aren’t happy.
“Yung proposal nga po na 90-horsepower mas maganda sa amin,” says Dagli. “Eh pagdumating na ang traktora eh 120-horsepower. Eh hindi na siguro kami mamimili.”
Farmers say they were not forced to accept the tractors. But it appears they were barely left with a choice.
Local cooperatives in Negros Oriental say they requested for 90-horsepower farm tractors, which would have been more suitable for their average sized farms.
But DAR bought 120-horsepower tractors instead.
Favored bidder?
In buying the tractors, commonly used for big farms, the government may have wasted P131 million in the Visayas region – P36 million in Negros Oriental alone.
Based on the bidding documents of the Department of Agriculture in 2013, a 90-horsepower tractor with tools cost about P2.2 million.
DAR purchased 120-horsepower tractors at P3.98 million each.
Farmers say the government could have saved P1.78 million per unit if they had bought tractors with less horsepower.
Negros Oriental Rep. Henry Pryde Teves, who is a farmer himself, claims that ill-suited tractors were purchased to favor a particular bidder – Equity Machineries, Inc.
The company has yet to give its comment.
Other suppliers, Teves says, were capable of supplying 120-horsepower tractors. But they just didn’t have any in stock because they were not very easy to sell because they use up a lot of fuel.
So there was only one supplier of these tractors.
DAR Undersecretary Perry Villanueva denies there was a favored bidder.
“We are aware that there are bidders who are not capable of complying with the requirements for turbo-charged and fuel-injected engines,” Villanueva says. “However, the purpose of procurement is not to accommodate everyone, so long as the bidding is competitive.”
He adds that the tractors were purchased based on the recommendations of the Sugar Regulatory Administration (SRA).
But SRA Administrator Regina Martin, says it had two recommendations back then – the 90-horsepower for average-sized farms and 120-horsepower for bigger farms.
Wrong tools
There’s also another problem.
The tools that DAR purchased are for 90-horsepower tractors – not for the high-powered 120-horsepowered ones. These included disk harrows.
“Not having the right tools would not let you have the right output in the operation,” Martin says. “With a heavy tractor, you’ll need also a heavy farm implement. If not, it will just fly.”
Farmers say they have no choice but to use the tractors – even if they’re the wrong kind, even if it will cost them more – to help the government not further waste millions of pesos.
No choice
Some farmers, though, say they could have put to better use the P1.78 million per tractor that the government could have saved if it bought 90-horsepower units.
Tony Castillo, president of San Julio Cooperative, says with just P1 million a farmer could buy an irrigation unit or a second-hand truck. He himself could have bought three second-hand trucks.
The question is: Why didn’t they complain?
The farmers signed a survey document for the purchase of 120-horsepower tractors before bidding took place. But the survey says they can’t be assured of a replacement if it turns out that the tractors weren’t what they need.
Castillo says, though, that the farmers were allowed to specify what they needed.
But then the tractors that arrived were 120-horsepower tractors.
“Nandiyan na yan eh,” he says.
And if they refused to accept the tractors, there was no assurance that they would be given a second set.
Agrarian Reform Undersecretary Perry Villanueva, said, however, that the farmers were not forced to sign the document.
He also denies that the bidding was rushed, as Representative Teves insisted, saying that the bidding took less than 15 days rather than the more usual one to four months
But Villanueva says there was an emergency.
“It was intended for the provinces affected by [Typhoon] Yolanda,” he says.
Teves was able to push for a congressional inquiry into the deal. The House of Representatives has already started the process.
****
If there is an issue or exposé you would like to disclose, contact jundelrosario@gmail.com or 09997720991/09063261921.
For more investigative reports, watch Headline News at 7 AM, Newsroom at 12 noon, Network News at 6 PM and Nightly News at 9 PM or visit cnnphilippines.com/investigative.
2 comments
department of agrarian racket
PNoy’s “Tuwid na Daan” term is about to end but easy money racket still prevails in many agencies of the government. DOTC, LTO, PNP, DAR, DENR, BOC, ETC,.. Ay naku! The only good thing about this is that the Ombudsman will soon catch up with this bad elements. Long live the Ombudsman!