SC orders Shangri-la Properties to pay construction firm almost P100 million in claims

THE Supreme Court has ordered Shangri-La Properties, Inc. (Shangri-La Properties) to pay BF Corporation (BFC) almost P100  million representing the latter’s claims for the construction of EDSA Plaza Project.

In a 25-page decision penned by now retired Chief Justice Lucas Bersamin, the Court en banc reinstated the ruling of the Arbitral Tribunal of the  Construction Industry Arbitration Commission (CIAC) granting BFC’s claim for variation of works.

It held that the Court of Appeals wrongly disregarded the specific variation orders that  carried the conformity of SLPI, which, when coupled with the letter dated May 9, 1991, satisfied the requisites under Article 1724 of the Civil Code.

Art. 1724 states that “the  contractor who undertakes to build a structure or any other work for a stipulated price, in conformity with plans and specifications agreed upon with the land-owner, can neither withdraw from the contract nor demand an increase in the price on account of the higher cost of labor or materials, save when there has been a change in the plans and specifications, provided such change has been authorized by the proprietor in writing; and the additional price to be paid to the contractor has been determined in writing by both parties.

“Accordingly, SLPI was liable to pay BFC for the latter’s completed works. As concluded by the Arbitral Tribunal and affirmed by the CA, the completion of the works was conclusively established,” the Court ruled.

As a consequence, the Court  affirmed the increase in the award for BFC’s unpaid progress billings for contract bills and change orders  in the amount of P35,372,005.57; reinstate the award for accomplished but unpaid change orders  in the amount of P6,201,278.50; reinstate the award for legal interest in the amount of P12,382,710.73; and the equal sharing of arbitration costs amounting to P857,229.88.

The SC said BFC is entitled to the award totaling to P54.81 million.

However, the SC denied BFC’s claim for damages caused by the nominated sub-contractors of SLPI .

It held that it would be wrong and unjust to hold SLPI liable for damages it did not cause.

Meanwhile, the SC affirmed the award issued by the Arbitral Tribunal in favor of SLPi which include the award for liquidated damages amounting to P780,000; award for other counterclaims amounting to P540,315; and equal arbitration costs amounting to P857,229.88.

The Court said both parties are liable to pay the awards plus legal interest of six percent per year from July 31, 2007, the date of the Arbitral Tribunal decision, until the decision becomes final and executory.

Afterwhich, the Court said the principal amount due, plus the interest of six percent per annum will likewise earn interest six percent per annum until full satisfaction.

The case arose from the contract executed between Shangri-La Properties and BFC concerning the Project. The trial court directed the parties to pursue the case with the CIAC.

An Arbitral Tribunal was created to receive the varying claims of the parties.

In its July 31, 2007 decision, the Arbitral Tribunal recognized BFC’s right to recover its claims for unpaid progress billings. It likewise acknowledged Shangri-La Properties’ entitlement to liquidated damages for the delays incurred in finishing the Project.

Both parties appealed the case before the Court of Appeals (CA).

The CA partially granted the petitions based on its appreciation of the facts and evidence presented.

As both parties were dissatisfied by the CA decision, they each filed a petition for review before the SC.

Home News Top News SC orders Shangri-la Properties to pay construction firm almost P100 million in claims

More from author

DOJ chief: PNP may have failed to follow protocols in war vs drugs

JUSTICE Secretary Menardo Guevarra has confirmed before the United Nation Human Rights Council (UNHRC) that the interagency review panel on...

NBI to conduct separate probe of ‘misencounter’ between cops, PDEA agents in QC mall

THE National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) will conduct a separate probe on the alleged misencounter between agents of the...

Government prosecutors still confident of clinching guilty verdict vs de Lima

GOVERNMENT prosecutors on Wednesday asserted that the camp of detained Sen. Leila de Lima failed to destroy the probative value...

BI chief raises alarm on new modus victimizing OFWs

THE Bureau of Immigration (BI) has warned aspiring overseas Filipino workers (OFWs) against fake immigration officers offering to facilitate...

SC asked to issue TRO anew vs anti-terror law

PETITIONERS seeking to declare as unconstitutional the Anti-Terrorism law have pleaded anew before the Supreme Court for the issuance of...

DOJ chief orders NBI to probe deeper into ‘mutation’ of pastillas scam in BI

JUSTICE Secretary Menardo Guevarra on Tuesday directed the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) to expand and dig deeper into...

Guevarra: I’ll take de Lima’s suggestion to prosecute Capones ‘under advisement’

JUSTICE Secretary Menardo Guevarra on Tuesday said the justice department would look into the suggestion of detained Sen. Leila...

Top News

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

More from this section

DLSU confers ‘Ka Pepe Diokno’ awards’ on Aquino, del Rosario, Carpio, Morales

FOUR former government officials who had roles to play in the country’s continuing multi-front struggle against Chinese expansionist moves in the South China Sea on Friday were conferred the “Ka Pepe Diokno Human Rights Award” in a virtual awarding...

Random posts

DA chief to AmCham: Invest in PHL’s agribusiness sector

The Department of Agriculture (DA) is encouraging the members of the American Chamber of Commerce of the Philippines (AmCham) to consider investing in the country’s agribusiness sector to help farmers attain “efficient management and delivery of agriculture and fishery...

BM Cycling Livestream

Graphic | BM Webinar

BM Broader Look Podcast