|
In stock
corporations, except for those shares of stock
classified as “preferred” or “redeemable” shares, each
share of stock as classified under Section 6 of the
Corporation Code of the Philippines is entitled to vote,
unless denied in the articles of incorporation or
declared delinquent under Section 67 of the same Code.
Also, except as otherwise provided by the articles of
incorporation and stated in the certificate of stock,
each share shall be equal in all respects to every other
share.
Under
Section 6 of the Corporation Code, it can likewise be
construed that common shares cannot be deprived of
voting rights. The fact that the shares are denominated
as common shares and have the same par value would
suppose that they are to be treated in equal footing
(SEC Opinion Letter to Atty. Orcullo dated December 12,
1996).
Where
the articles of incorporation and the certificate of
stock are silent on the matter of voting rights, all
issued shares, regardless of their class nomenclature,
shall be considered to have equal voting rights (SEC
Opinion Letter to Mr. Otsuki dated July 16, 1996). The
Corporation Code is explicit that the moment a stock
becomes delinquent, the holder thereof loses his right
to vote. The Corporation Code provides that no
delinquent stock shall be voted for or be entitled to
vote or to representation at any stockholders’ meeting
(Section 71, Corporation Code).
Most
statutes provide that a stockholder whose shares are
pledged shall be entitled to vote such shares until the
shares have been transferred into the name of the
pledgee, and thereafter the pledgee shall be entitled to
vote the shares so transferred (Model Bus Corp. Act & 31
(8) cited in Fletcher Cyclopedia Corporations, Vol. 5,
p; 177).
Even
when shares are on the books in the name of the
pled-gee, he has not the title, as the right to vote is
in the pledgor, in the absence of agreement to the
contrary (Fletchers, Vol. 5 p. 178 citing Italo
Petroleum Corp. v. Producers’ Oil Corp., 20 Del. Ch.
283, 174 A 276).
The
right to vote at a stockholders’ meeting depends upon
the ownership of the stock as disclosed by the stock and
transfer book [repeat: stock and transfer book] of the
corporation, and a registered stockholder must be
allowed to vote irrespective of any question of bona
fides (Fletcher, Supra, Sec. 2023). Therefore, mere
possession of the stock certificate, even if in the name
of the holder, does not per se, give the right to vote
such stock. Treasury shares, on the other hand, shall
have no voting rights as long as such stock remains in
treasury (Sec. 57, Corporation Code of the
Philippines).
In this connection, whenever the general corporation law
disqualifies shares from voting on any matter, they are
not considered outstanding for the determination of a
quorum at any meeting to act upon, or the required vote
to approve action upon, that matter under any other
provision of the general corporation law or articles or
bylaws (Ballantine & Sterling, California Corporation
Law, Vol. 1A, 1982 ed., sec 171.01 at 9-32). |